Skip to main content

Jim Parkman Law

Available 24/7
Call: 205-573-6001
Request Free Consultation
100% Secure and Confidential
Menu
Menu

Healthcare Fraud

Contact us

Locations

Our Team

About Jim Parkman

Our Blog

Read Posts

Alabama Healthcare Fraud Lawyer

In 2005, the federal government put HealthSouth CEO Richard Scrushy on trial in Birmingham for what prosecutors called a $2.7 billion accounting fraud. He was the first chief executive in America tried under the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, the government spent years building its case, and fifteen former executives had already pleaded guilty and agreed to testify against him. The jury acquitted him on every one of the 36 counts.
Jim Parkman led that defense. If you are a physician, pharmacist, practice owner, or healthcare executive facing a fraud investigation in Alabama, that verdict matters to you for one simple reason. The prosecutors handling your case know exactly who he is, and they know what happened the last time the government bet a headline healthcare fraud case against him in a Birmingham courtroom.
Received a subpoena, a target letter, or a visit from federal agents? Do not answer questions before you talk to a lawyer. Call Jim Parkman Law at (205) 573-6001 for a free, confidential consultation.

What This Page Covers

Why Healthcare Fraud Cases Are Different

jim-parkmen-federal-lawyer

Healthcare fraud is not like other criminal charges. Most defendants are professionals with clean records who never imagined being on the wrong side of a federal investigation. The alleged crime usually lives inside billing records, coding decisions, and referral relationships governed by some of the most complicated regulations in American law. Billing rules change constantly, they are frequently ambiguous, and honest providers get them wrong every day without any intent to defraud anyone. Federal prosecutors know this, and it does not slow them down. Birmingham sits at the center of one of the largest healthcare economies in the Southeast, anchored by the UAB medical complex and hundreds of practices, hospitals, home health agencies, and suppliers across the state. That concentration of Medicare and Medicaid money makes Alabama a steady producer of fraud investigations, and the government's data analytics now flag providers automatically when their billing patterns sit outside statistical norms. Being an outlier is not a crime. Treating sicker patients, serving rural populations, or simply being good at what you do can make your numbers look unusual. But an algorithm does not know that, and once the file lands on a prosecutor's desk, someone has to explain the story behind the numbers. That job belongs to your defense lawyer, and the earlier it starts, the better it goes.

The Federal Laws Behind Alabama Healthcare Fraud Cases

Most healthcare fraud prosecutions in Alabama are federal, brought by the U.S. Attorney’s Office in the Northern District of Alabama and tried at the Hugo L. Black United States Courthouse in downtown Birmingham. Several statutes do the heavy lifting.
The healthcare fraud statute, 18 U.S.C. Section 1347, makes it a crime to knowingly execute a scheme to defraud any healthcare benefit program, government or private. A conviction carries up to 10 years in federal prison per count, up to 20 years if the violation caused serious bodily injury, and up to life if it resulted in death.
The Anti-Kickback Statute prohibits offering, paying, soliciting, or receiving anything of value to induce referrals of federal healthcare program business. Marketing arrangements, medical directorships, space leases, and speaker fees that look routine in other industries can become federal felonies in healthcare, with up to 10 years in prison per violation.
The False Claims Act is the government’s civil weapon, and it often runs alongside or ahead of the criminal case. It carries triple damages plus a penalty on every single false claim, and since each billed procedure can count as a separate claim, the numbers become ruinous fast. Many FCA cases begin as qui tam lawsuits filed under seal by whistleblowers, frequently a former employee or business partner, who stand to collect a share of the recovery. You can be under investigation for months before you learn the case exists.
The Stark Law restricts physician self-referrals for designated health services. It is a civil statute, but Stark problems routinely become the foundation for False Claims Act cases and add pressure to any parallel criminal matter.
Wire fraud, mail fraud, and conspiracy charges get stacked on top of nearly every indictment, because every electronic claim and every mailed check is a potential separate count. That stacking is deliberate. It raises the sentencing exposure and hands prosecutors leverage to pressure a plea. Understanding how to attack the stack, count by count, is a core part of the defense.

Who Gets Investigated, and How It Starts

Our healthcare fraud practice defends physicians, dentists, pharmacists, nurse practitioners, chiropractors, practice managers, billing companies, home health and hospice agencies, DME suppliers, lab owners, and executives of healthcare companies. The allegations follow familiar patterns: upcoding and unbundling, billing for services not rendered or not medically necessary, kickback arrangements dressed up as marketing or consulting agreements, telehealth billing schemes, and prescription or controlled substance issues that pull in the DEA alongside everyone else.
Investigations rarely announce themselves politely. They surface as an OIG subpoena for records, a civil investigative demand, an audit that suddenly escalates, a grand jury subpoena, agents appearing at your office or your home, or a target letter from the U.S. Attorney. Each of those documents means something different about where you stand, and each demands a different response. What they have in common is this: the government has been working on your case long before you heard about it, and everything you say and produce from this point forward is evidence.
Two rules apply the moment you learn you are under investigation. First, do not talk to agents without counsel, no matter how informal the conversation feels. Lying to a federal agent is its own felony, and even truthful answers given without preparation can lock you into a version of events before you have seen a single document. Second, do not touch the records. Nothing converts a defensible billing case into an obstruction prosecution faster than altered or deleted documents.

How We Defend Healthcare Fraud Cases

Every healthcare fraud case turns on intent. The government must prove you knowingly and willfully set out to defraud, not that your billing was imperfect, and that distinction is where these cases are won. Complex, shifting billing rules cut in the defense’s favor when the story is told correctly. So does evidence that you relied on billing staff, consultants, compliance advice, or the carrier’s own guidance. So does a paper trail showing you self-reported errors or repaid overpayments when you found them.
The defense also attacks the government’s numbers. Prosecutors love statistical extrapolation, taking a small sample of claims and projecting it across years of billing. Those models have assumptions, and assumptions can be dismantled with the right experts. Kickback allegations get tested against the statute’s safe harbors, because arrangements that fit within them are legal by definition. And in qui tam driven cases, the whistleblower’s motives, financial stake, and personal history become fair game.
When a case can be resolved before indictment, early intervention is worth everything. Presenting the defense to prosecutors while they are still deciding what to charge has ended investigations quietly, turned criminal referrals into civil settlements, and kept clients’ names out of the newspaper. That window closes at indictment. And when the government will not bend, it needs to know that trial is not a bluff. That is the difference Jim Parkman brings to the table. Most white collar lawyers negotiate with the government hoping to avoid trial. Prosecutors in Birmingham know Jim has taken the biggest healthcare fraud case in state history to a jury and won all of it.

What a Conviction Actually Costs a Healthcare Professional

The prison exposure is only the beginning. A healthcare fraud conviction brings restitution and fines that can reach millions, and federal sentencing guidelines drive sentences by loss amount, so the government’s inflated calculations must be fought at every stage. Beyond the criminal penalties sits exclusion from Medicare, Medicaid, and all federal healthcare programs, which for most providers is a professional death sentence regardless of what the judge imposes. Licensing boards open their own proceedings. Hospital privileges disappear. Payors terminate contracts. Defending these cases means defending on every front at once, criminal, civil, and administrative, with a strategy that accounts for how each one affects the others.
Your license, your practice, and your freedom are all in play. Get a defense strategy from the lawyer who won the HealthSouth trial. Call (205) 573-6001.

Alabama Healthcare Fraud FAQs

Not necessarily, but you are unquestionably under investigation, and how you respond will influence whether charges ever come. The subpoena's scope tells an experienced defense lawyer a great deal about the government's theory. Responding requires care: you must comply, but production should be managed, privileged materials protected, and contact with investigators channeled through counsel. Never respond on your own.

It happens in almost every case, because agents intentionally arrive unannounced. What matters now is finding out what was said, stopping further uncounseled contact, and instructing staff on their rights going forward. Employees can decline interviews, and the company can provide counsel. Damage control works far better early than late.

Intent. The government must prove you knowingly and willfully schemed to defraud, not that errors occurred. Overpayments from honest mistakes are handled through repayment and audits every day in Alabama without anyone being prosecuted. The danger zone is when volume, pattern, or a cooperating witness lets prosecutors argue the mistakes were deliberate. That is precisely the argument a defense lawyer exists to defeat.

Most serious healthcare fraud cases in Alabama are federal because Medicare and Medicaid money is involved, and they are prosecuted in the Northern District of Alabama at the federal courthouse in Birmingham. Alabama's Medicaid Fraud Control Unit also brings state cases. Jim Parkman has defended clients in both systems for more than 45 years, and the federal courthouse in Birmingham is where he won the Scrushy verdict.

Yes. Licensing boards operate on a lower standard of proof than criminal courts, and board action can proceed regardless of how the criminal case ends. Exclusion from federal programs is a separate administrative threat. A complete defense coordinates all three tracks from the start, because a win in criminal court can be hollowed out by an undefended board proceeding.

Not before someone who tries cases has examined the evidence. Plea offers reflect the government's confidence, and that confidence often rests on extrapolated loss numbers and cooperator testimony that do not survive scrutiny. Sometimes a negotiated resolution is genuinely the right outcome, and when it is, you want it negotiated by a lawyer the government knows will try the case if the terms are wrong.

Talk to Jim Parkman Before You Talk to Anyone Else

Birmingham Office

850 Corporate Pkwy #100,
Birmingham, AL 35242

Available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week

Call: 205-573-6001
Healthcare fraud investigations move slowly and then all at once. The providers who come through them with their licenses and their liberty intact are almost always the ones who got counsel involved at the first sign of trouble, before the interviews, before the production, before the story got written by someone else. Jim Parkman has spent his career defending people the government was certain it could convict, in the same Birmingham courtrooms where your case will be decided.
Free, confidential consultation with an Alabama healthcare fraud lawyer. Call Jim Parkman Law at (205) 573-6001, day or night.

What Clients Say

I had the privilege of working with Jim Parkman at Jim Parkman Law, and I cannot speak highly enough of his exceptional skills as a criminal trial lawyer. From the very beginning, Jim demonstrated an unmatched level of expertise, confidence, and dedication to my case. His deep knowledge of criminal law, combined with his ability to communicate effectively and persuasively in the courtroom, truly sets him apart from others in his field. Jim’s preparation and attention to detail were extraordinary. He not only took the time to understand every aspect of my situation but also explained the legal process in a way that was clear and reassuring. During the trial, his presence was commanding, and his arguments were both compelling and strategically brilliant. It was evident that he genuinely cared about achieving the best possible outcome for me. Thanks to Jim’s outstanding representation, I felt supported every step of the way and confident that my case was in the best possible hands. If you are looking for a top-notch criminal trial lawyer who combines experience, skill, and integrity, I wholeheartedly recommend Jim Parkman at Jim Parkman Law. He is truly one of the best in the business. He genuinely cared about me. He was motivated, had great energy, and was fully present and didn't rush me. He listened carefully and knew the facts of my case right off the top of his head. These little things make a client feel seen, taken care of, and truly represented.”
C Rosenboom
I am incredibly grateful for the outstanding support we received from Jim Parkman Law during a very sensitive and life-changing time for our family. A loved one recently experienced a significant change in status that opened the door to a potential release, and navigating that shift felt overwhelming. The team at Jim Parkman Law handled everything with professionalism, clarity, and compassion. They took the time to explain each step of the process, answered our questions thoroughly, and made sure we understood what to expect moving forward. Their customer service was not only responsive but genuinely caring. During moments of uncertainty, they remained steady and reassuring, which made a meaningful difference for our family. If you are looking for a legal team that combines knowledge, integrity, and sincere client support, I highly recommend Jim Parkman Law. He genuinely cared about me. He was motivated, had great energy, and was fully present and didn't rush me. He listened carefully and knew the facts of my case right off the top of his head. These little things make a client feel seen, taken care of, and truly represented.”
Sangita Hickmam
Jim Parkman Law is defined by integrity, professionalism, and strong advocacy. They are known for their diligent trial work, sound judgment, and genuine commitment to their clients. Jim Parkman leads this team of dedicated professionals, who are not only knowledgeable and responsive, but more importantly kind and compassionate to the needs of their existing clients as well as prospective new clients. From my experience visiting this office, anyone who calls or walks through the door is treated with respect and care. Collectively, the team creates a culture of trust, accountability, and excellence that sets the firm apart. THIS is the team to trust. He genuinely cared about me. He was motivated, had great energy, and was fully present and didn't rush me. He listened carefully and knew the facts of my case right off the top of his head. These little things make a client feel seen, taken care of, and truly represented.”
Ruth Flora
Parkman law did a great job and helped me out tremendously with my two serious traffic tickets! They got me out of trouble, Mrs Joy was extremely helpful and friendly and cared, Mr Parkman is the real deal he fought for me until the end, and Mrs Bre at the front desk was extremely helpful and answered phone and answered my questions every single time I called. Parkman law 10/10 I definitely recommend THEY CARE!!He genuinely cared about me. He was motivated, had great energy, and was fully present and didn't rush me. He listened carefully and knew the facts of my case right off the top of his head. These little things make a client feel seen, taken care of, and truly represented.”
BT Terry
The true effort and dedication behind Jim and his team is simply incredible. The biggest part though, when I had my miscarriage, they did everything they could to allow me the time I needed without the pressure of court. Jim stood up for me and did his job and never made me feel alone, hopeless or confused. His team is incredible. They never put the money before my wellbeing. They have a true passion for law that surpasses any firm. Jim, you’re a God send! I highly recommend Parkman law and I refuse to use anyone else! Thank you Jim, Joy, and Tara! I’m so thankful for all you’ve done.
Alyssa Trimble
The Parkman Law Firm always goes the extra mile to handle pain staking details of every case they handle. Mr. Parkman and his staff are very gracious, courteous, and true professionals. There is an old saying; you get what you pay for. The Parkman Law Firm is worth every penny, and then some. They will be my first call if the need ever arises.
Paul Meadows
Jim is one of the beat attorneys I have encountered over the years. Not only did he handle my criminal case he went far and beyond to make sure my family knew everything that was going on with my case. I highly recommend Jim Parker to handle any case!
T Iui
Jim Parkman gave me exceptional representation. I am so thankful for his help and for all the traveling he did down to the gulf coast! If you need someone that will go above and beyond and won’t take no for an answer Jim Parkman is your guy!
Chad Sterling
The service I received from your law firm was amazing! I appreciate the communication and everything you’ve done for my finance. Staff if very professional, willing and ready to get the job done! I will definitely if needed in the near future to refer my friends and family to your law firm. Thank you for all that you do!
Angela Edwards
Jim and Joy helped settle my high conflict divorce with ease and they were very responsive. I was in contact almost daily with the office so I always knew what was going on. Joy especially was attentive and comforting throughout a really tough time for me and my kids, and I appreciate her caring heart so much ❤️
Katy Collingwood